Israeli realism/realism about Israel

  1. @laseptiemewilay the discussion reveals that principal parties have only vague, often contradictory definitions of “state” @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 20:45:29, 2014-07-16
  2. @laseptiemewilay combined with weak understandings of “sovereignty” and its relationship to “state” @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 20:46:20, 2014-07-16
  3. @laseptiemewilay I think Israeli resistance to so-called two-state solution is much more fundamental @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 20:52:33, 2014-07-16
  4. @laseptiemewilay may have been easier to suppress recognition of “facts on the ground” in various ways, at different times @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 20:56:34, 2014-07-16
  5. @laseptiemewilay but both sides have continually re-discovered their respective state concepts to be mutually exclusive @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 20:57:17, 2014-07-16

  6. @laseptiemewilay did you ever read that interview with Benny Morris when he asked to be excused for not dissolving into tears? @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 21:02:48, 2014-07-16
  7. @laseptiemewilay (he was being sarcastic) @djpressman in reply to laseptiemewilay 21:03:23, 2014-07-16
  8. @laseptiemewilay “If you expected me to burst into tears, Iā€™m sorry to disappoint you. I will not do that.” in reply to laseptiemewilay 23:45:33, 2014-07-16
  9. @laseptiemewilay I often think of it in next to Arnon Soffer’s notorious statements from around the same time about Gaza and the future in reply to laseptiemewilay 23:51:56, 2014-07-16
  10. @laseptiemewilay See Soffer here, tho he later amended some of his views on degree of Israeli withdrawal 00:11:22, 2014-07-17
  11. @laseptiemewilay I’ve not yet seen good evidence that Israeli realism doesn’t mean a Soffer-Morris line (see also ONE STATE, TWO STATES) 00:14:29, 2014-07-17

Soffer’s notorious statement about the Gaza withdrawal, which he strongly favored – that it meant Israel would be required to “kill and kill and kill” at the Gaza border possibly for another century – seems also somewhat prophetic, at least on the evidence so far, up to the latest news. See also Andrew Sullivan’s recent posts on “Understanding the Permanence of Greater Israel” – especially the one today describing Greater Israel as likely eventual American position (or open position) too: “; Sullivan extensively quotes Daniel Goldman/”Spengler” – from an essay in which Goldman extends common comparison of situation in MENA to the 30 Years War – to same general effect (in Tablet!).

0 comments on “Israeli realism/realism about Israel

Commenting at CK MacLeod's

We are determined to encourage thoughtful discussion, so please be respectful to others. We also provide a set of Commenting Options - comment/commenter highlighting and ignoring, and commenter archives that you can access by clicking the commenter options button (). Go to our Commenting Guidelines page for more details, including how to report offensive and spam commenting.

    1 Pings/Trackbacks for "Israeli realism/realism about Israel"
    1. […] and something else for the Palestinian Arabs, as I have noted many times (most recently in “Israeli Realism” and “The 1.x-State Solution“). Even the most generous offers to the Palestinian […]

    Commenter Ignore Button by CK's Plug-Ins

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *